Tuesday, April 13, 2004

I usually find these reader commentaries a bit over the top on the Buzzflash site, but this one makes some interesting observations about how we might percieve the war if there were another imperial power invading.

If the Invading Boots Were Not Our Own -- A BuzzFlash Reader Contribution: "If Russia had invaded Iraq last year against the advice of the US, and everything that has happened to the US soldiers had happened to Russian soldiers, I wonder if the US would be as angry with the insurgent Iraqis as we are now? Would we even call them 'insurgents' or would we call them 'Iraqi defenders'? Would the word at the US water coolers be anti Iraqis or anti Russians? Would we hear rumbles that the US should go into Iraq to help the invaded Iraqis? Would we feel sympathy for the Iraqis as the Russian soldiers tore down the doors of Iraqi homes and forced the families out on the street? When tragic events happened in Iraq would we be supportive of the Russians or would we say that they should have seen it coming? If, during all this death and war, we discovered that Putin had lied to his people in order to receive their support for the Iraq invasion, what would we say? Would we say that Putin should be jailed for his deceit? Would we say that he was justified if he lied to his people because Saddam was a corrupt leader? "

No comments: